Categories: Exchange

The Microsoft Exchange Replication service does not appear to be running on Exchange Server

When trying to move a mailbox database from one Exchange 2010 DAG server to another there’s an error displayed: The Microsoft Exchange Replication service does not appear to be running on “PassiveMailboxServer”. Make sure that the server is operating, and that the services can be queried remotely.

💥 Problem Description

The error itself seems to be very descriptive but there are actually lots of reasons it can be happening. In our case the Microsoft Exchange Replication server was up and running. It was even reporting Healthy status. Still the error was there during every move.

Error Message
The Microsoft Exchange Replication service does not appear to be running on “MBX2”. Make sure that the server is operating, and that the services can be queried remotely.

Exchange Management Shell command attempted: Move-ActiveMailboxDatabase -Identity ‘MDB01’ -ActivateOnServer ‘MBX2’ -MountDialOverride ‘None’

🛠️ Solution

Add missing groups to Administrators on all Exchange servers:

Organization Management

Exchange Trusted Subsystem

In our case it was clearly broken because SID's were not resolving correctly.

Those 2 groups are crucial for Exchange 2007, Exchange 2010 and Exchange 2013 to work properly regardless of the problem. Make sure that Exchange Trusted Subsystem group holds all your Exchange Servers and Organization Management group holds your Administrative account.

This post was last modified on June 6, 2025 19:06

Przemyslaw Klys

System Architect with over 14 years of experience in the IT field. Skilled, among others, in Active Directory, Microsoft Exchange and Office 365. Profoundly interested in PowerShell. Software geek.

Share
Published by
Przemyslaw Klys

Recent Posts

Supercharging Your Network Diagnostics with Globalping for NET

Ever wondered how to run network diagnostics like Ping, Traceroute, or DNS queries from probes…

2 weeks ago

Automating Network Diagnostics with Globalping PowerShell Module

Are you tired of manually running network diagnostics like Ping, Traceroute, or DNS queries? The…

2 weeks ago

Enhanced Dashboards with PSWriteHTML – Introducing InfoCards and Density Options

Discover new features in the PSWriteHTML PowerShell module – including New-HTMLInfoCard, improved layout controls with…

3 weeks ago

Mastering Active Directory Hygiene: Automating SIDHistory Cleanup with CleanupMonster

Security Identifier (SID) History is a useful mechanism in Active Directory (AD) migrations. It allows…

3 weeks ago

Upgrade Azure Active Directory Connect fails with unexpected error

Today, I made the decision to upgrade my test environment and update the version of…

3 weeks ago

Mastering Active Directory Hygiene: Automating Stale Computer Cleanup with CleanupMonster

Have you ever looked at your Active Directory and wondered, "Why do I still have…

3 weeks ago